• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Crypto Reporter

Online magazine about cryptocurrencies, NFTs, DeFi, GameFi and other blockchain technologies

Visit Consensus in Hong Kong | February 1-3, 2027
Visit Consensus in Miami | May 4-6, 2027
Use promo code CRYPTOREPORTER15 for a 15% discount on tickets
  • News
    • News Feed
    • Crypto news in brief
    • Stats & trends
  • Press Releases
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events
      • CryptoCon, Sydney (November 28–29, 2026)
      • iCrypto Awards: People’s Choice, Dubai (December, 2026)
      • Digital Asset Forum, London (February 1-2, 2027)
      • Consensus, Hong Kong (February 1-3, 2027)
      • Digital Assets Week, Dubai (February 4, 2027)
      • Digital Assets Week, Hong Kong (March 3, 2027)
      • 6th FinTech Week & Expo, Paris (May 4-5, 2027)
      • Consensus, Miami (May 4-6, 2027)
    • Past Events

“Smart contracts” aren’t at all contracts but are lines of code

February 9, 2023 By Crypto Reporter PR

The European Crypto Initiative considers certain aspects of the version of the Data Act, voted at the European Parliament’s ITRE Committee earlier today, to be potentially problematic for the development of the crypto industry.

The Data Act, intended to regulate Internet-of-Things (IoT) devices’ use of data, also regulates smart contracts for data sharing in Article 30. We consider the mention of smart contracts in the Data Act particularly important, as it is the first time they are regulated on an EU level. Therefore, the understanding of what a smart contract means, even if for the purposes of developing IoT devices, poses a risk of becoming the foundation of the institutions’ broader regulatory approach towards them.

To be more precise, the main issues we see with the Parliament’s version of Article 30 are the following:

The draft argues for the robustness of the smart contract, which is welcomed, but it also requires access control. However, any access control regarding the data stored on the blockchain would be impossible due to the transparent nature of the blockchain – there is no way to prevent specific parties from reading it. Nonetheless, there is a way to have robust access control for modifying smart contracts or adding data robustness. It is very important to be clear about the scope of this requirement.

Furthermore, the text calls for ensuring the safe termination and interruption of smart contract transactions – the issue here is that smart contracts are often modular, and having the ability to be interrupted can break other dependent applications. We believe that smart contract developers should have the freedom to design the smart contract in the way they deem appropriate and use the features made available by distributed ledger technology (DLT). We worry the regulation defining the design of a smart contract in such detail would make it impossible for a whole range of technology solutions to be used. We do encourage interoperability and standard creation coming from the industry and taking into account the current development of the technology.

What we find alarming is that the text calls for equivalence between smart contracts and what seems to be described as legal contracts. If that is really what the proposal implies, then it should be mentioned that there shouldn’t be an equivalence between a smart contract and a legal contract as they differ in their very nature. For this novel technology, it is important to focus on the substance and not the naming – “smart contracts” aren’t at all contracts but are lines of code. Smart contracts oftentimes facilitate and automate the execution part of a contract or agreement. There can not be equivalence, legal certainty or protection solely within the code that the smart contract represents because of its inability to write complex text in human-readable language.

Article 30 also calls for the protection of confidentiality of trade secrets – at the current state of the development of DLT, specifically public blockchain, the public address, the amount of the transaction made, and the time of the transaction, among potentially other information, are public and visible to anyone. The information mentioned will most likely be part of the “trade secrets” for which protection and confidentiality are impossible to guarantee. Therefore, this provision in the Data Act prohibits the use of public blockchains for smart contract development for the scope of this regulation in cases where trade secrets are revealed.

Filed Under: Press Releases

Primary Sidebar

Press Releases

Akash Unveils Akash Forwards, Bringing Commodity-Style Forward Trading to AI Compute

November 19, 2026

Sumsub Identity Fraud Report: U.S. Has World’s Largest Fraud Network Detected as AI Agents Open New Gaps

November 18, 2026

Sentora and Fireblocks Dynamic partner to simplify yield access for crypto and fintech businesses

November 18, 2026

SWFI to Host G20 Digital Asset Round Table at G20 Investment Week in Miami on the Sidelines of the G20 Leaders’ Summit

November 18, 2026

How to Earn Solana as a Beginner: Copy Trading and Meme Coins on Banana Gun

November 17, 2026

iCrypto Awards

Digital Asset Forum, London (February 1-2, 2027)

Consensus, Hong Kong (February 1-3, 2027)

6th Fintech Week & Expo, Paris (May 4-5, 2027)

Consensus, Miami (May 4-6, 2027)

Footer

Crypto Reporter is an online magazine about cryptocurrencies, NFTs, DeFi, GameFi and other blockchain technologies
About us
Contact us
Submit press-release

Search

2017-2026 Crypto Reporter